Thursday, March 5, 2015

A letter from Jerry, a frustrated high school student who plays baseball and has sesamoiditis

From: Jerry

Hi Mr. Unger, my name is Jerry Carroll. I recently bought your book on sesamoiditis. I play baseball and it is so frustrating to play with this pain. I have a bipartite chronic fracture in the sesamoid. I wear orthodics from my foot doctor, but they're not really doing anything to help the pain and inflamation. It would be very much apreciated if you could take some time to answer my questions. What kind of sesamoiditis did you have? How much tumeric should I take? Does doing 3 times of ibuprofen a day going to be that much different then 4? How do I do acupunture and ultra sound back to back, for example is there a doctor that has both of those tools with them? And does this 2 week regimine take away the pain for a short period of time, long period of time, or forevor. What has your experience been like with your program?



Jerry,

All of these answers are in the book. I will repeat them here.

What kind of sesamoiditis did you have?
I had sesamoiditis in both feet. Minor fracture and deformity of the sesamoid bone which made it look totally split on the x-ray.  I was in pain just walking/standing and tried to never walk barefoot which really hurt.  I opted not to have crutches but you may want 1 crutch until the fracture is gone.

How much tumeric should I take?
1000mg of tumeric as long as you feel no side-effects and no stomach problems – 2 times per day
** Do not take ibuprofen AND Tumeric.  One or the other.  They are both taken to hedge against inflammation and are not healthy to take simultaneously.

Does doing 3 times of ibuprofen a day going to be that much different then 4?
• Yes it does. You need to keep the level of anti-inflammatory (ibuprofen) in your system constantly.  200mg tablets are effective for 6 hours max.   If you sleep 8 hours then just dose up as soon as you wake up and right before bed.
• If you have acid reflux problems (heart-burn), take the ibuprofen with an ant-acid (zantac)
• Do not TAKE ibuprofen indefinitely.  You will want to cycle it for 2 week periods.  This will help you to determine where you are at pain-wise as well when you get off of it.  The amount you take depends on your size, age, effect… Do not take more than 1000mg per dose.   Taper the dosage as well… Example:   Week 1: 1000mg – 4 times per day, Week 2: 600mg – 4 times per day.

2 weeks on, 2 weeks off (Get off all anti-flammatories for a 1 day to check your progress (No tumeric and no ibuprofen and no icing.  Switch to Tumeric during your 2 weeks off once you have assessed how much pain is still there.  Also be sure to ice as often as possible, no more than 20 minutes per session.  Do not do ICE and then HEAT back to back ever.  20 minutes of ice on the ball of foot then 20 minutes with nothing than 20 minutes ice - repeat)

** Get a small bucket that will fit both of your feet… A storage bin container from Walmart.  Fill it up with ice and water and put your feet in that to ice it OR get Dixie cups, fill with water and freeze them and rub the ice on your foot..  OR goto walgreens and get the ice Velcro strap to put on your foot.

The ice bucket works the best.

How do I do acupuncture and ultra sound back to back, for example is there a doctor that has both of those tools with them?
Try acupuncture and STIM-acupuncture (STIM is electrodes hooked up to the pins) to see which one works better for you.     Find someone who does both.

Acupuncture treatment first followed by Ultra-sound for like 10 minutes followed by massage (Hard but not hard to hurt the area), follow this by ice for 20 minutes.
** Do not run, walk a lot or carry anything heavy on the days you do acupuncture, you could do more damage than good.  (basically anything that irritates your balls of feet on the days you do acupuncture)

And does this 2 week regimen take away the pain for a short period of time, long period of time, or forever?
It reduces the inflammation and with less inflammation you will have less pain.   The fracture has to heal 100% before the pain will be gone forever.  You are doing the 2 week regimen to help the fracture heal and to keep the inflammation down because you are causing inflammation whenever you put any pressure on the ball of your foot for any reason (standing, walking, lying in bed causes problems if your foot isn’t elevated)

Eventually the pain will be gone forever if you stay on top of this.  While you have a problem the pain will come back as soon as you get off the ibuprofen or as soon as you walk on it funny and hurt the area.   You can test your pain best by walking barefoot for 20 feet or so on cement.

What has your experience been like with your program?
2012 – 50+ Marathons and Ultra-marathons (up to 100 mile runs)
2013 – 50+ Marathons and Ultra-marathons (up to 100 mile runs)
2014 – 50+ Marathons and Ultra-marathons (no 100 milers until next month)

I got the sesamoiditis in May of 2013.   As I said, walking, standing, etc. hurt my foot but with what I detailed in book, I was able to run long distances because I switched my foot strike to a mid to back foot strike which means I wasn’t hitting the balls of my feet when I foot strike to run.

You cant change your foot strike when you walk because it wont feel good.  Running like this is different in case you need to stay in shape for baseball.

** Swimming laps and doing hard sessions on a indoor SPIN bike will help to keep your cardio up and not put pressure on the foot.  i.e. Cross-train

So the lesson is Walking, Standing, Standing with weight in your hand, putting any direct pressure is bad.   Anything you can do that takes the pressure off the ball of your foot is okay.  You will know if it hurts.

You have to stay on top of this for it to heal otherwise it can literally take years, surgery or it will never heal right and it will always hurt.

Last but not least…. Ditch whatever orthodic the doctor gave you and go find a Sports Pedorthist… This is very important.  The Sports Pedorthist is a master orthodic maker and can keep adjusting the orthodic until all the pressure comes off of the ball of your foot when you walk.  Bet on about $200-400.  You should make sure you put these in your walking shoes.   If you can run in them great but I have found it hard to run with these so I use a normal sports/running orthodic from the store in my running shoes.  You walk way more than you will run anyway.

If you really think your orthodic from the doctor is working and you have no pain walking than use it but if you have any pain while walking in that orthodic than spend the money and go to the Sports Pedorthist.  Google one your area or find one close to you so you can go into the store and get measured by him/her and so you can go back if you need adjustments made.

** The fracture has to heal before you should even try to run.

Stay off of it until the fracture heals.  Go back in and get a new X-Ray done to see if it has healed in a month.

** You might want to try a different Sports Orthopod or Sports Podiatrist to give you a second opinion on whether or not you truly have a fracture as opposed to just being born with it deformed which can look JUST like a fracture (I was born with deformity and a LOT of people have this).

I hope you get over this fast.  It’s a terrible problem to have.   No one likes to be side-lined by injury.   Make sure you keep your spirits up.

Take CALCIUM supplements and STAY AWAY FROM CAFFEINE, any sort of drugs including nicotine, do not drink alcohol at all and try to eat healthy and organic meats and vegetables.  Stay away from SUGAR and try to follow a diet that is meant for anti-inflammation.

You do this to heal faster and you do this to help in case you get any sort of depression from being benched which a lot of people get.  If you find you attitude is bad or worse than usual, you are probably depressed.   Eating healthy will keep your spirits high and your attitude positive.

If you start to get a negative attitude your chances of doing everything you can to heal start to diminish. Stay positive.  Focus on healing and focus on what you will do once you are healed.   I know this might sound hokey but it isn’t. Believe me.  All of the major athletes spend a lot of time training their mind.

I hope this helps.

If the information works for you I would appreciate it if you could give the book a good review on Amazon.com

http://www.amazon.com/The-Sesamoiditis-Cure-definitive-understanding/dp/1495466108/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&qid=1412812659&sr=8-4&keywords=greg+unger

Keep me posted and let me know how everything goes.

Greg



Greg,

So did you have the same stress fracture as me because my fracture was said to be never curable because I noticed it almost a year after the fracture. So do you think the fracture in the sesamoid could just go away. Just curious, does your sesamoid on an x ray show no more fracture after you did the 2 week regiment?




Jerry,

Yes on my left foot I did have a fracture but it was a hairline fracture not a complete break off of the bone.   If you have a complete break you will most likely have to have surgery to repair or remove the bone.

Nothing will cure a complete break, you will need surgery if it hurts and you cannot play sports.

A hairline fracture should heel but I am not your doctor so I would seek a second opinion if that is what your primary doctor said and see a specialist.

It not being curable doesn’t make any sense.  If you noticed it a year afterwards it may be because you never let it heal properly and kept re-fracturing it.  It needs to heal properly. You need to stay off of it.  You may need it casted.

My book and advice is what you do to heal faster but nothing is going to fix a fracture in 2 weeks.  My book also details how to not re-fracture the foot by staying off of it.

Curing this is not a 1 day problem and its not a 2 week problem.  It may take longer and will if you still have a fracture.

Once the fracture is healed there will still be a lot of work involved to get rid of the pain in order to get back to sports.  You don’t have to fracture the sesamoid to have sesamoiditis.  Sesamoiditis can exist without a fracture and so can the pain, for a long time after any fracture heals.

Yes, I think the fracture (unless it is totally broken in half) will heal.  I have not seen your x-rays and cannot make a judgement call on your specific case.

Again, see a sports orthopedic surgeon or sports podiatrist and get a second opinion or even a third opinion.

My x-rays show no more fracture at all.

Good luck with everything and I hope that helps.

Greg Unger


A letter from Gary about his foot problems when he runs

Gary wrote:

Hi Greg,

Ran across your sesamoiditis cure book on the web. My pain only occurs during running or prolonged standing. Last April I got a pair of Chung Shi rocker shoes for running plus an orthotic from Foot Solutions, and that took care of the problem for 8 months. Since the pain returned in December, I’ve noticed that the Chung Shi compresses my toes, and I found out I do better with older well-worn  Asics shoes with a fairly wide toe box. The old shoes, however, still give some discomfort near the end of my 6-mile run (on back roads, mostly gravel/tar), which I currently do every other day. With no running or no prolonged (4+ hours) standing, I have no pain or discomfort at all.

So what I’m interested in is another pair of shoes with a wide toe box and a non-flexing forefoot and good cushioning under the forefoot, like the Saucony Hurricane 13 recommended by Dr. Jenny Sanders here: http://drshoereviews.com/2012/01/

In looking over the book preview, it looks like you’re giving a lot of therapies for treating the pain, but what I’m interested in is finding some running shoes to PREVENT the pain. Does your book have any advice in that regard?

Thanks, Gary



Gary,

I hate to hear it came back!  Prolonged standing will definitely cause major problems.  I actually cover standing and sitting with pressure on the forefoot in the book.   Both create enough of a problem that pain and inflammation happen.   

I looked into the Chung Shi shoes awhile ago but all the research I did led to a conclusion that they really didnt do anything for the majority of people (A few people liked them).   I am a math guy so I look at things from a probability standpoint to try and be as efficient as possible when coming up with solutions to things.

I personally use Asics Kayano's because they work the best for me.  If you look at the reviews (Shoe websites, amazon, etc.), you will find they are very highly rated and reviewed.

Altra's are made specifically to allow for a larger toe splay (toe separation upon strike) so they may be more comfortable for you.   Hoka's with orthodics work well too.  There is no shoe that by itself will be a solution.  You have to have the correct orthodic, room in the shoe and support from a good sole especially when running or standing for long periods of time.

You have to have plenty of room in the running shoe no matter what.   Keep in mind that you should be able to goto a wider size in regular running shoes because the orthodic should keep your foot in place and the "way" you lace your shoes should keep your foot snug and your toes from hitting the front of the shoe.

The correct shoe also really depends on your height and weight. (Height comes into play due to your nature center of balance when running, i.e. do you lean forward, back, etc.)

To answer your question, yes, my book goes over shoe solutions.

It covers orthodics.  Unless that orthodic was specifcally made for your foot "and" for your condition, it is not the best solution.   That might be evident from the fact that you still have pain.

The solutions I propose in the book allowed me to run road marathons literally every weekend with virtually no pain and I had sesamoiditis bad and bilateral. ( I race a lot ).  I also did the Leadman race series in Leadville, Colorado with it.

Long story long... 

You have to get the right orthodic for your foot "and condition". Also, you have to have someone who can tweak that orthodic until you have no pain.  The specific cause of sesamoiditis is a little different in everyone so tweaks need to happen even with a custom orthodic.

Staying off your foot completely (boot and crutches) for most people work.  I on the other hand have a real problem with being sidelined so I subscribe more to the "find a way" idea of getting things done.   

A few simple changes should get you back to running without any pain.    Standing for "long" periods of time has its own problem due to gravity (forcing blood down).   You must ice the ball of foot repeatedly to get around this problem.   Carry ice packs with you (in a cooler if needs be).  NSAIDs should be taken when you know the standing will happen.   Proactive is key.

Whatever you do, stay on top of it.   If some action hurts you have to stop it until you find a way to do the action without pain or inflammation.   i.e. I am not saying to stop the action, I am saying to find a way to do it without pain :)

I hope this helps... If you buy the book, great... You are supporting my race registrations ;)  If you don't buy the book then I sincerely hope the problem goes away for you.   I can't stand when anyone is sidelined.   

If you do find a way that works for you keep me posted.  I would love to hear about it.

Greg



Hi Greg,

Thanks so much for your very detailed and helpful reply.

The same day after I emailed you, I found a local store which I hadn’t previously been aware of which carries the Altra shoes.

The owner, Jeff, has quite a few years of experience with fitting running shoes and helping people with foot issues.

When I described my history and problem, he thought it might be Morton’s neuroma rather than sesamoiditis. He watched me run and noticed that I tended to strike the floor with my whole foot rather than heel to toe. Long story short, he put me in a pair of Brooks Ravenna 5, size 11.5EE (my usual shoe size in 10.5 to 11). When I ran 6 miles the next day, I had NO foot pain at all and not even a sensation that the ball of my foot was bothered at all. Two days later (yesterday) I ran 5 miles with the same result. And for the rest of that day and all day today, I’ve spent most of the day standing or walking around and have not had any discomfort, even without using my orthotics.

To clarify, I’m now running in the Brooks shoe with the wide “stabil step” orthotics I got off the shelf at Foot Solutions along with New Balance Supportive Cushioning Insoles (IUAS 3810 -Previously Ultra Arch).

I won’t say this is a permanent solution until I have at least 6 pain-free months, but it appears I’m on the way towards one, at least.

I’m still not sure (and I don’t think Jeff is, either) whether my problem is sesamoiditis, Morton’s neuroma or metatarsalgia, although maybe all of them have similar methods of prevention and correction. Does your book cover the other conditions as well as sesamoiditis?

Thanks again for taking the time to write me such a thorough and considerate response. 

Kind regards,
Gary



Hi Gary!

Great to hear Gary! Yes, my book covers all of the best modalities for treating mortons neuroma, seismoditis, turf toe and more! For a few bucks it is worth the read!

Thanks
Greg